Gail Hairston

By

College: Arts and Sciences

USGS Maps for Central U.S. Overstate Earthquake Hazard in Western Kentucky

Published: Oct 31, 2016

LEXINGTON, Ky. (Oct. 31, 2016) — A new publication from the Kentucky Geological Survey at the University of Kentucky concludes that the national earthquake hazard maps developed by the U.S. Geological Survey seriously overstate the hazard in the New Madrid Seismic Zone, which includes western Kentucky, resulting in overly stringent building codes and policies.

 

Research that resulted in the publication also suggests that economic development is reduced and insurance costs are unnecessarily higher in western Kentucky because of the overstated hazard. The publication, “Earthquake Hazard Mitigation in the New Madrid Seismic Zone: Science and Public Policy,” is available at the KGS publications website here. The publication was developed from the master’s degree thesis of principal author Alice M. Orton.

 

The study points out that, with very few damaging earthquakes in the New Madrid Seismic Zone, assessing the zone’s actual earthquake hazard is difficult. In such cases, mathematical earthquake models based on the San Andreas Fault and other western U.S. seismic zones have been developed to calculate seismic hazard in the New Madrid region. Geologic differences between the western United States and the central part of the country limit the applicability of western U.S. data to the central United States. This leads the study’s authors to conclude that the application of the most commonly used mathematical model to determine the hazard in the central United States, probabilistic seismic hazard analysis, is flawed and its results misinterpreted and misused for public policy decisions. The authors point out that large uncertainty is inherent in earthquake hazard assessment for regions like the central United States.

 

The 2008 USGS seismic hazard maps, which are the basis of building codes and other policies, depict higher earthquake ground-motion hazards for the New Madrid Zone than in San Francisco or Los Angeles, even though the California coast has been affected far more frequently and seriously by seismic activity than the central United States has been.

 

“At each step in this process (using the hazard maps to develop public policies), any uncertainties in the underlying calculations were accepted, compounded and codified as mitigation requirements,” the study concludes. “Government officials, economic development agencies and businesspersons in the Jackson Purchase Region of Western Kentucky have complained that overly stringent seismic mitigation policies adversely affect economic development in the region by discouraging new businesses from locating in the area.”

 

As part of the study, 29 officials, professionals and other private citizens were interviewed to assess understanding and attitudes about the earthquake threat in Western Kentucky as well as computerized scenarios of economic and other effects from earthquakes in the New Madrid Seismic Zone. The New Madrid area was also compared to the affected area of the Wenchuan, China, 7.9-magnitude earthquake of May 2008, because earthquake ground-motion values are similar in both areas.

 

The study concludes, “Whether justified or not, the predicted extreme high ground-motion hazards for the New Madrid Seismic Zone and the resulting stringent seismic design requirements have an impact on communities in the New Madrid area, Western Kentucky in particular. The perception in Western Kentucky is that overstated seismic-hazard estimates have led to overly stringent building codes and other detrimental public policies, ultimately suppressing economic growth.”

 

Among the recommendations of the study:

· Continue earthquake monitoring and seismic research and improve hazard assessment, as well as seismic risk assessment.

 

· Improve the level of trust between the public and seismic experts through more transparent communication and more understandable documentation of information and methods.

 

· Provide additional education for nonscientists and structural design and construction professionals, as well as help with appropriate emergency response plans and preparation activities.

 

· Revise the New Madrid Seismic Zone earthquake hazard on the national seismic hazard maps.

 

The Kentucky Geological Survey is a research institute within the University of Kentucky. KGS staff work to increase the understanding of the state’s geology and disseminate their research results to the citizens, communities, State agencies, businesses and industries of Kentucky.

 

 

UK is the University for Kentucky. At UK, we are educating more students, treating more patients with complex illnesses and conducting more research and service than at any time in our 150-year history. To read more about the UK story and how you can support continued investment in your university and the Commonwealth, go to: uky.edu/uk4ky. #uk4ky #seeblue

 

 

MEDIA CONTACT: Gail Hairston, 859-257-3302, gail.hairston@uky.edu

central_us_seismic_hazard_map.jpgwestern_us_seismic_hazard_map.jpg
October
 
 
 
 
 
 
1
Louis Zoellar Bickett: Saving Myself
Let's Talk!
Sat
2
Louis Zoellar Bickett: Saving Myself
Let's Talk!
Sun
3
Louis Zoellar Bickett: Saving Myself
Let's Talk!
Let's Talk!
Let's Talk!
Let's Talk!
Let's Talk!
Empower: People of Color Support Group
Empower: People of Color Support Group
Mon
4
Louis Zoellar Bickett: Saving Myself
Let's Talk!
Wildcat Wellness Workshop: EXPRESSIONS
Wildcat Wellness Workshop: EXPRESSIONS
Wildcat Wellness Workshop: EXPRESSIONS
Wildcat Wellness Workshop: EXPRESSIONS
Wildcat Wellness Workshop: EXPRESSIONS
Homecoming Royalty Programing
Flu Shots
Tue
5
Louis Zoellar Bickett: Saving Myself
Let's Talk!
Let's Talk!
Let's Talk!
Let's Talk!
Let's Talk!
Let's Talk!
Wildcat Wellness Workshop: MEDITATION
Wildcat Wellness Workshop: MEDITATION
Wildcat Wellness Workshop: MEDITATION
Wildcat Wellness Workshop: MEDITATION
Wildcat Wellness Workshop: MEDITATION
Horticulture Club Farm Market Sale
Horticulture Club Farm Market Sale
Horticulture Club Farm Market Sale
Free HIV Screenings! #UKGYT
Wed
6
Louis Zoellar Bickett: Saving Myself
Let's Talk!
Let's Talk!
Let's Talk!
Let's Talk!
Let's Talk!
Let's Talk!
Let's Talk!
Let's Talk!
Let's Talk!
Wildcat Wellness Workshop: YOGA
Wildcat Wellness Workshop: YOGA
Wildcat Wellness Workshop: YOGA
Wildcat Wellness Workshop: YOGA
Wildcat Wellness Workshop: YOGA
OCSS Off-Campus Housing Fair
Flu Shots
Street Fair
Thu
7
Louis Zoellar Bickett: Saving Myself
Let's Talk!
Family Weekend: James W. Stuckert Career Center Open House
Family Weekend Check-In and Resource Fair
Family Weekend: MacAdam Student Observatory
Fri
8
Louis Zoellar Bickett: Saving Myself
Let's Talk!
Family Weekend Tent Party
Keeneland Breakfast with the Works & Out-of State Family Meet-and-Greet
Sat
9
Louis Zoellar Bickett: Saving Myself
Let's Talk!
Family Weekend DNT 101: A Taste of the Kentucky Doughnut Trail
Family Weekend: See the Sun!
Family Weekend: Sunday Lunch at Historic Spindletop Hall
Sun
10
Louis Zoellar Bickett: Saving Myself
Let's Talk!
Let's Talk!
Empower: People of Color Support Group
Mon
11
Louis Zoellar Bickett: Saving Myself
Let's Talk!
Wildcat Wellness Workshop: EXPRESSIONS
UK Elder Care Lunch & Learn - Why Pre-Planning Is So Important
Andy Steves' Europe: City-Hopping on a Budget
Tue
12
Louis Zoellar Bickett: Saving Myself
Let's Talk!
All Student Survey
Let's Talk!
Wildcat Wellness Workshop: MEDITATION
NSE (National Student Exchange) Information Session
NSE Information Session
Flu Shots
Study Sounds
Wed
13
Louis Zoellar Bickett: Saving Myself
Let's Talk!
All Student Survey
Let's Talk!
Let's Talk!
Wildcat Wellness Workshop: YOGA
Thu
14
Louis Zoellar Bickett: Saving Myself
Let's Talk!
All Student Survey
Black and Blue: Critical Issues on Race and Policing in the US
Fri
15
Louis Zoellar Bickett: Saving Myself
Let's Talk!
All Student Survey
Sat
16
Louis Zoellar Bickett: Saving Myself
Let's Talk!
All Student Survey
Sun
17
Louis Zoellar Bickett: Saving Myself
Let's Talk!
All Student Survey
Midterm of Fall 2016
Let's Talk!
Empower: People of Color Support Group
Artist Conversation: Donald Lipski
Mon
18
Louis Zoellar Bickett: Saving Myself
Let's Talk!
UK Women's Forum Board Meeting
Wildcat Wellness Workshop: EXPRESSIONS
The 2016 Federal Elections: Crisis Point in a Dysfunctional Political System
Flu Shots
Greek Park Pictures #2
Tue
19
Louis Zoellar Bickett: Saving Myself
Let's Talk!
Let's Talk!
Wildcat Wellness Workshop: MEDITATION
UK Horticulture Club Farm Market
Flu Shots
Panel Discussion: Frontiers in Genetics and Genomics
Wed
20
Louis Zoellar Bickett: Saving Myself
Let's Talk!
Let's Talk!
Let's Talk!
Wildcat Wellness Workshop: YOGA
Kentucky Artist Appreciation Fair
Media and Diversity Talk
Thu
21
Louis Zoellar Bickett: Saving Myself
Let's Talk!
Banking on DNA: Thinking about new genetic tests in comparative contexts
R.C. May Photography Lecture Series: Judy Linn
UK Volleyball
Fri
22
Louis Zoellar Bickett: Saving Myself
Let's Talk!
UK Woman's Club Fund Run
Sat
23
Louis Zoellar Bickett: Saving Myself
Let's Talk!
Sun
24
Louis Zoellar Bickett: Saving Myself
Let's Talk!
Let's Talk!
Empower: People of Color Support Group
Mon
25
Louis Zoellar Bickett: Saving Myself
Let's Talk!
Wildcat Wellness Workshop: EXPRESSIONS
2016 Lab Safety Fair
Tue
26
Louis Zoellar Bickett: Saving Myself
Let's Talk!
Let's Talk!
Wildcat Wellness Workshop: MEDITATION
NSE (National Student Exchange) info session
UK Horticulture Club Farm Market
Kentucky Statewide Trauma and Emergency Medicine Symposium
Flu Shots
Wed
27
Louis Zoellar Bickett: Saving Myself
Let's Talk!
Kentucky Statewide Trauma and Emergency Medicine Symposium
Let's Talk!
Let's Talk!
Wildcat Wellness Workshop: YOGA
Open in Action: Open Educational Resources Contribute to Student Success
19th Annual Trick or Treating in the Residence Halls
Thu
28
Louis Zoellar Bickett: Saving Myself
Let's Talk!
Kentucky Statewide Trauma and Emergency Medicine Symposium
Fri
29
Louis Zoellar Bickett: Saving Myself
Let's Talk!
41st Annual Meeting of Kentucky Association of Teachers of History
Sat
30
Louis Zoellar Bickett: Saving Myself
Let's Talk!
Sun
31
Louis Zoellar Bickett: Saving Myself
Let's Talk!
Let's Talk!
Empower: People of Color Support Group
Mon
 
 
 
 
 
Oct 31
Let's Talk! 10/31/2016

Repeats every 7 days until Tue Dec 13 2016 .
Tue, 11/01/2016

Repeats every 7 days until Wed Dec 14 2016 .
Wed, 11/02/2016

Repeats every week until Wed Dec 14 2016 except Wed Nov 23 2016.
Wed, 11/02/2016

Wed, 11/02/2016

Reset Page